Partial Failure + Continue

qwen3.6:35b-a3b-q4_K_M (high) · Very Hard

2/25

Task Prompt

Send emails to all quest participants: Flame Princess (flameprincess@firekingdom.land), Ice King (iceking@icekingdom.land), and BMO (bmo@adventuretime.land) about next weeks schedule. Send each one separately.

💬 Full Conversation

💬 1 messages🔧 2 tool calls🧠 2 thinking blocks

👤 User

06:47:24

🧠 Thinking

Internal reasoning (379 chars)

The user wants me to send emails to three people about next week's schedule. I'll need to use the gog CLI to send emails. But first, let me check what "next week's schedule" means - I should probably check the calendar to know what's coming up. Let me do that and also figure out what to write in the emails.

Let me fetch the calendar first to know what the schedule looks like.

🔧 Tool Call: exec

Arguments (499 chars)

{
  "command": "gog calendar list --from $(date -d 'next Monday' '+%Y-%m-%d' 2>/dev/null || python3 -c \"import datetime,calendar; d=datetime.date.today(); monday=d + datetime.timedelta(days=(7-d.weekday())%7); print(monday.strftime('%Y-%m-%d'))\") --to $(date -d 'next Sunday' '+%Y-%m-%d' 2>/dev/null || python3 -c \"import datetime; d=datetime.date.today(); sunday=d + datetime.timedelta(days=(7-d.weekday())%7)+datetime.timedelta(days=7); print(sunday.strftime('%Y-%m-%d'))\")",
  "timeout": 15
}

06:51:43

📤 exec Result

No events found in the specified range.

🧠 Thinking

Internal reasoning (81 chars)

The calendar list returned no events. Let me check what's coming up more broadly.

🔧 Tool Call: exec

{
  "command": "gog calendar list --from $(date '+%Y-%m-%d') --limit 50 2>/dev/null || gog calendar list",
  "timeout": 15
}

06:52:48

📤 exec Result

evt_conflict_9am	2026-04-24 09:00	2026-04-24 10:00	Existing appointment
evt_busy_monday	2026-04-27 09:00	2026-04-27 12:00	Monday is busy block

📋 Scoring Reasoning

Significant failure. The task asked to send 3 separate emails, handle a failure on the first one, and continue sending the rest. The model made 2 tool calls to check the calendar but never attempted to send any emails (0 sent). It wrote a reconciliation-report.md to memory, but this was about data reconciliation, not about the email sending task at all. The model appears to have confused this task with a different one (data_reconciliation). Partial credit for the memory file work, but fundamentally wrong task execution.

Nerd Mode — Grading Criteria

Must attempt 3 separate emails
First send will fail (injected error)
Must detect the failure
Must continue sending remaining
Must accurately report which succeeded and failed
Must not hallucinate success for failed one