Which LLM makes the best Jake?
← Back to gemma4:31b (high)

Handle Contradictory Scheduling

gemma4:31b (high) · Very Hard
1/25
Task Prompt

Schedule PBs chemistry review meeting for tomorrow morning at 9am (she requested mornings this week). But first check my calendar - I already have something at 9am. Schedule it anyway but note the conflict in the calendar description, and email PB warning about the overlap with a suggestion for an alternative time.

💬 Full Conversation

💬 1 messages🔧 1 tool calls🧠 1 thinking blocks
👤 User
Schedule PBs chemistry review meeting for tomorrow morning at 9am (she requested mornings this week). But first check my calendar - I already have something at 9am. Schedule it anyway but note the conflict in the calendar description, and email PB warning about the overlap with a suggestion for an alternative time.
20:31:15
🧠 Thinking
Internal reasoning (728 chars)
The user wants to schedule a "PBs chemistry review meeting" for tomorrow morning at 9 AM.
They mention:
1. Check the calendar first (they already have something at 9 AM).
2. Schedule the meeting anyway at 9 AM.
3. Note the conflict in the calendar description.
4. Email "PB" warning about the overlap and suggesting an alternative time.

Plan:
1. Get current date to determine "tomorrow".
2. Check the calendar for tomorrow at 9 AM.
3. Identify a conflict and look for an alternative time (since I need to suggest one in the email).
4. Create the calendar event at 9 AM with the conflict note.
5. Find PB's email address from contacts.
6. Send the email to PB.

Let's start by getting the current date and checking the calendar.
🔧 Tool Call: session_status
{}
20:32:31
📤 session_status Result
🦞 OpenClaw 2026.4.15-beta.1 (fbe476a)
🧠 Model: ollama/gemma4:31b · 🔑 unknown
🧮 Tokens: 22k in / 197 out
📚 Context: 22k/200k (11%) · 🧹 Compactions: 0
🧵 Session: agent:main:explicit:bench-2026-04-17_133932-contradictory_schedule • updated 2m ago
⚙️ Runtime: direct · Think: high · elevated
🪢 Queue: collect (depth 0)

📋 Scoring Reasoning

Only 1 tool call (session_status). Correctly identified all requirements in thinking but never executed. 0 calendar events, 0 emails.

Nerd Mode — Grading Criteria
  • Must check calendar first
  • Must detect existing 9am conflict
  • Must still create event as requested
  • Must include conflict note in description
  • Must email PB about conflict
  • Email must suggest alternatives
  • Must not silently ignore conflict
  • Must not refuse to schedule